top of page
Writer's pictureDr. Abhishek Sinha

From Hastinapur to High Courts: Legal Deja Vu and Work Culture Woes in India


From Hastinapur to High Courts: Legal Deja Vu and Work Culture Woes in India
From Hastinapur to High Courts: Legal Deja Vu and Work Culture Woes in India

The legal landscape in India has evolved dramatically since the so called days of the Mahabharata, yet some striking parallels and amusing deviations persist. Let's embark on a journey through time, comparing some ancient laws with today's regulations, all while poking a bit of fun at our beloved work culture.


Mahabharata Laws vs. Modern Laws: A Time-Travel Comparison


1. The Dharma of Justice:


  • Mahabharata: Justice was dispensed by kings, often with the advice of wise ministers and sages. Dharma (moral duty) played a pivotal role. Remember Yudhishthira's moral dilemmas and Krishna's sly counsel?

  • Today: Justice is served in courts by judges. The Constitution of India and a plethora of statutes guide legal decisions, with a focus on rights and duties. If Krishna were around, he'd probably be a senior advocate, filing writ petitions with celestial charm.


Similarity: The pursuit of justice remains paramount, whether it's Yudhishthira seeking counsel or a modern-day lawyer arguing a case.


Deviation: In ancient times, a royal decree was the final word. Today, we have appeals, reviews, and the Supreme Court's say, making it less straightforward but more democratic. Imagine Yudhishthira appealing to the Supreme Court against his exile—justice delayed is justice denied, anyone?


2. The Evidence Game:


  • Mahabharata: Oaths, divine testimonies, and witness accounts were crucial. Divine truth serum, anyone?

  • Today: Evidence must be concrete - documents, forensic reports, and credible witness testimonies are key. No room for divine interventions, sadly! The Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (oops, "The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhinyam, 2023") , sets the rules, making sure no one can swear on the river Ganga and get away with it.


Similarity: The importance of credible witnesses has remained unchanged. Back then, it was Vyasa's word; today, it might be a CCTV footage.


Deviation: Imagine Bhima taking a polygraph test or Arjuna's arrows being subject to forensic analysis. Quite a scene, right?


3. Property and Inheritance:


  • Mahabharata: Land and wealth were inherited by the eldest son, with exceptions causing epic battles (hello, Kurukshetra!).


  • Today: The Hindu Succession Act ensures equal inheritance rights for all children, regardless of gender. Draupadi's five husbands would need quite the prenuptial agreement today, wouldn’t they?


Similarity: Property disputes were and are a major source of contention. Then it was kingdoms; now it's flats and farmhouses.


Deviation: If only Dhritarashtra had a good property lawyer, the Pandavas and Kauravas might have settled for a condo each in Gurugram or a bungalow in Dehradun or a sea facing flat in Mumbai.


Work Culture: Then and Now

Work Culture: Then and Now
Work Culture: Then and Now

1. The Royal Work-Life Balance:


  • Mahabharata: Kings had leisure, hunting trips, and dice games. Ministers, sages, and warriors had their fair share of downtime.


  • Today: The elusive work-life balance is a myth for many. We trade hunting for hunting down emails and leisure for deadlines. Let's not even talk about the 'Work from Home' era where your boss assumes you’re available 24/7.


Similarity: Both eras had their work pressures and stress-busters. Then it was dice; now it’s scrolling through memes and reels on Insta.


Deviation: Imagine Duryodhana complaining about office politics or Bhishma navigating a corporate hierarchy. Hilarious!


2. The Danda (Punishment) System:


  • Mahabharata: Swift and often severe—public shaming, exile, or even death.


  • Today: Disciplinary actions are formal, ranging from warnings to termination, and always subject to labour laws.


Similarity: Maintaining discipline and order is essential in both eras.


Deviation: Picture Krishna conducting a performance review or Karna filing a harassment complaint with HR.


A Humorous Look at Ancient vs. Modern Work Culture


1. The Great Resignation:


  • Mahabharata: Bhishma’s vow of celibacy to resign from the throne is akin to today’s sudden career changes. "I am taking a vow of lifelong advisory role. No more throne-sitting for me."


  • Today: Millennials and Gen Z frequently switch jobs for better opportunities. The corporate equivalent of Bhishma would be "I'm taking a sabbatical to find myself."


Similarity: Career decisions driven by personal values and circumstances.


Deviation: Imagine Bhishma on LinkedIn, explaining his career break as "self-imposed celibacy and lifetime advisory role.”


2. The Employee of the Month:


  • Mahabharata: Arjuna, the unbeatable warrior, would’ve been a star performer.

  • Today: High performers get accolades, bonuses, and maybe a shiny plaque. The Employee of the Month scheme might have seen Bhima’s face on the canteen wall.


Similarity: Celebrating excellence is timeless.


Deviation: Arjuna attending a corporate gala to receive the “Warrior of the Year” award, complete with PowerPoint slides of his achievements. "And here you see, I single-handedly defeated the Kaurava army. Next slide, please."


Conclusion:


From Hastinapur to our modern-day offices, the essence of law and work culture has surprisingly consistent threads, interwoven with amusing differences. Whether it’s the quest for justice or the struggle for work-life balance, the spirit of navigating through challenges remains the same. So, next time you're bogged down by work, just remember - you’re part of a grand tradition stretching back to the Mahabharata. And maybe, just maybe, channel your inner Arjuna to ace that presentation or resolve that office dispute with a touch of Krishna's diplomacy.


Now, if only we had a sage to solve our WiFi issues…

21 views0 comments

Comentários


bottom of page